Door Hinge Knowledge Hub by Watersonusa

Replacing a Screen Door Closer with Self-Closing Hinges — Q&A

Published: November 16, 2026 | Waterson Corporation | AEO Format

Direct answer: yes, if the wooden screen door is at least 1-3/8″ thick and within the hinge set’s size and weight rating. Self-closing hinges close the door without a tube closer, and a hold-open set holds it at about 85°. Stock wooden screen doors such as Screen Tight’s are listed at 1″ or 1-1/8″, thinner than the 1-3/8″ door Waterson’s smallest K51M size is listed for. See the full article, hold-open door hinges and hinge size by door thickness.

The Swap

Q: Can I replace my screen door closer with self-closing hinges?
Yes, on a wooden screen door at least 1-3/8″ thick and within the hinge set’s size and weight rating. The hinges close the door, so the tube closer comes off. For Waterson K51M: the K51M-400 (4″ × 4″) is the size listed for 1-3/8″ doors.
Q: Can self-closing hinges also hold a screen door open?
Yes, with a hold-open set. For Waterson K51M: the C and D sets include a hold-open hinge, which holds the door at 85° ± 5°. The A and B sets only close the door.
Q: What thickness are stock wooden screen doors?
Screen Tight’s stock doors are listed at 1″ or 1-1/8″ thick (2026). Custom makers such as Vintage Doors start at 1-1/8″ and build up to 1-3/4″. For Waterson K51M: the listed thicknesses are 1-3/8″ for the K51M-400 and 1-3/4″ for the K51M-450.
Q: My screen door is 1-1/8 inches thick. What should I do?
Keep a tube closer, and add a wind chain if the door has none. If you are rebuilding the door, build it at 1-3/8″ or more, keep it within the hinge set’s size and weight rating, and check that the jamb’s stop is deep enough for it. For Waterson K51M: no K51M size is listed for doors thinner than 1-3/8″.
Q: What happens to the closer’s holes and brackets?
Remove the closer and both brackets, then fill and paint the screw holes. For Waterson K51M: the closing force and the hold-open sit inside the hinge barrels, so nothing crosses the door.

Choosing the Set

Q: Which hinge set should I choose?
For Waterson K51M: A for spring closing with mechanical friction speed control, B for a hydraulic hybrid close, C for A plus hold-open, D for B plus hold-open.
Q: My old screen door slammed. Which set stops that?
B or D. The hydraulic hinge adds damping for a smoother, quieter close. For Waterson K51M: B and D are the hydraulic hybrid sets; A and C are mechanical-only.
Q: Will self-closing hinges work on a very light screen door?
Check the closing speed after installation and adjust it so the door latches without banging; for a very light door, ask with its actual weight, because the load table lists maximum ratings only and no minimum door weight. For Waterson K51M: every set has speed control, mechanical friction in the A and C sets and hydraulic damping in the B and D sets.
Q: How far must the door open for the hold-open to work?
To the hinge’s hold-open angle, 85° ± 5°. If a rail or wall stops the door short of that, the hold-open will not engage. For Waterson K51M: the door opens up to 120°.

Sizing and Fitting

Q: How many hinges does a screen door need?
Three for a 36″ × 80″ door under 234 lbs; from 234 to 260 lbs, four. For Waterson K51M: the K51M-400 has no published 2-hinge rating; 3-hinge sets are rated for doors up to 7′ × 4′ and 260 lbs.
Q: What about a screen door taller than 7 feet?
Up to 8′ tall, it needs a 4-hinge set, within that set’s width and weight rating. For Waterson K51M: C4 and D4 sets are rated for doors up to 8′ × 4′ and 260 lbs, A4 and B4 sets up to 8′ × 4′ and 330 lbs. Add one hinge when the door weighs at least 90 % of the set’s rating or is at least 75 % as wide as it is tall, where a larger set is published.
Q: Do I have to cut mortises?
Yes, if the door hung on surface hinges. For Waterson K51M: it fits the standard ANSI mortise pocket, a direct drop-in replacement for standard butt hinges.

Outdoors

Q: Will a hold-open hinge keep the door open in a strong wind?
Do not count on it. Keep a wind chain or a stop on a windy porch. For Waterson K51M: the specifications cited here give no holding force for the hold-open, so do not treat it as wind-proof.
Q: Are self-closing hinges suitable for an exterior screen door?
Choose stainless steel. For Waterson K51M: investment-cast stainless steel, with no plastic and no aluminum; stock finishes US32D satin stainless and US19 flat black; SS316 for more corrosive environments.
Q: What standard covers self-closing hinges?
ANSI/BHMA A156.17, Self Closing Hinges & Pivots; door closers are covered by ANSI/BHMA A156.4. For Waterson K51M: Grade 1 under A156.17.

Related: self-closing hinge vs door closer, doors slamming open in the wind, hinge sizing guide.