Can I Replace My Screen Door Closer with Self-Closing Hinges?
Published November 16, 2026 • 6 min read • For homeowners, carpenters and door installers
Yes, if the wooden screen door is at least 1-3/8″ thick and within the hinge set’s size and weight rating. A set of self-closing hinges closes the door from the hinge barrels, so the tube closer comes off, and a hold-open set also holds the door open at about 85°. Stock wooden screen doors such as Screen Tight’s are listed at 1″ or 1-1/8″, thinner than the 1-3/8″ door that Waterson’s smallest K51M size is listed for, so a rebuild is the time to make the door thicker.
Quick Facts
- Minimum door thickness for Waterson: 1-3/8″, with the K51M-400 (4″ × 4″)
- Screen Tight stock wooden screen doors: listed at 1″ or 1-1/8″ (2026)
- Hold-open: Waterson C and D sets, at 85° ± 5°
- Hinge count: 3 for a 36″ × 80″ door under 234 lbs; 4 for a door over 7′ and up to 8′
- Wind: keep a wind chain or stop; the cited specifications give no holding force for the hold-open
Why Owners Want the Closer Gone
A pneumatic tube closer does two jobs with two parts. The spring and air cylinder pull the door shut. The hold-open washer, slid along the rod against the cylinder, wedges the rod so the door stays open. Wright Products, which makes many of these closers, says the washer “only works as a wedge” to keep the door open. Many doors also carry a wind chain. Ideal Security sells its storm door chain to stop a gust from swinging an open storm or screen door too far and damaging the door and the closer.
A cabin owner who was rebuilding an old wooden screen door wrote to ask whether hinges could take over from the tube closer the door had used for years, and also hold the door open. That is exactly what a hold-open hinge set does. The first number to settle is how thick the new door will be.
Self-closing hinges move the closing force into the hinges themselves. There is no tube across the door, no bracket screwed to a thin stile, and no washer to slide. In a Waterson set, the closing force and the speed control are inside the hinge barrels, and the hold-open is in one hinge of the C or D set. For the wider comparison, see self-closing hinge vs door closer.
Step 1: Measure the Door Thickness
Measure at the hinge edge of the door, not at the screen panel.
| Door thickness | What to do |
|---|---|
| 1″ or 1-1/8″ (stock doors such as Screen Tight’s) | No Waterson K51M size is listed for this thickness. Keep a tube closer, or build the new door thicker. |
| 1-3/8″ | Waterson K51M-400 (4″ × 4″) |
| 1-3/4″ | Waterson K51M-450 (4-1/2″ × 4-1/2″) |
Waterson K51M sizes are listed against door thickness: the K51M-400 for 1-3/8″ doors and the K51M-450 for 1-3/4″ doors. Custom screen door makers build thicker doors: Vintage Doors says its screen doors start at 1-1/8″ and can go up to 1-3/4″ for custom projects. If you are rebuilding the door anyway, a 1-3/8″ door opens up the hinge option; check that the jamb’s stop is deep enough for the thicker door. Our hinge size by door thickness article has the full chart.
The K51M is a mortise hinge that fits the standard ANSI mortise pocket. A screen door that hung on surface hinges will need hinge pockets cut in the door edge and the jamb.
Step 2: Pick the Set — Self-Closing Only, or With Hold-Open
Waterson sells its hinges as sets, named by a letter and the number of hinges.
| Set | What it does | Hold-open |
|---|---|---|
| A | Spring closing, mechanical friction speed control | No |
| B | Hydraulic hybrid: a hydraulic hinge for a smoother, quieter close | No |
| C | The A set plus hold-open | Yes, 85° ± 5° |
| D | The B set plus hold-open | Yes, 85° ± 5° |
In the C and D sets, one hinge is an SB hinge: spring power on top and a hold-open feature on the bottom that holds the door at 85° ± 5°. Open the door to that angle and it stays there. The door must be able to swing to the hinge’s hold-open angle (85° ± 5°); if a porch rail or a wall stops it short of that, the hold-open will not engage, so check the swing first. The K51M opens up to 120°. More on how it works: hold-open door hinges.
If the old door slammed, choose B or D: the hydraulic hinge adds damping for a smoother, quieter close. On any set, check the closing speed after installation and adjust it so the door latches without banging.
Step 3: Count the Hinges
A homeowner planning a pair of exterior screen doors taller than 7 feet asked us which hinges to use. Before we could size them, we needed the thickness, the height and the weight.
The K51M-400 has no published 2-hinge rating, so a 1-3/8″ screen door takes at least three hinges. A K51M 3-hinge set (A3, B3, C3 or D3) is rated for doors up to 7′ × 4′ and 260 lbs; a C4 or D4 4-hinge set for doors up to 8′ × 4′ and 260 lbs; an A4 or B4 set for doors up to 8′ × 4′ and 330 lbs.
Waterson starts from the fewest hinges whose rating covers the door’s height, width and weight, then adds one hinge when the door weighs at least 90 % of that set’s rating or is at least 75 % as wide as it is tall, where a set with one more hinge is published. A 36″ × 80″ screen door is 45 % as wide as it is tall, so if it weighs under 234 lbs (90 % of 260 lbs) it takes a 3-hinge set; from 234 to 260 lbs it steps up to four. A door over 7′ and up to 8′ tall takes a 4-hinge set, provided its width and weight are within that set’s rating. Weigh the door before you order. The hinge sizing guide walks through the numbers.
Step 4: Plan for Wind and Weather
A hold-open hinge is not a wind lock. The specifications cited here give no holding force for the hold-open, so do not treat it as wind-proof: on a windy porch keep a wind chain or a stop as well, as you would with a tube closer. Our article on doors slamming open in the wind covers stops and other hardware.
The hinges are built for outdoor use. A K51M is investment-cast stainless steel, with no plastic and no aluminum. Stock finishes are US32D satin stainless and US19 flat black powder coat, and Waterson uses SS316 for more corrosive environments such as coastal sites; see 304 vs 316 stainless steel hinges.
Alternatives Considered
- Keep the tube closer: the right answer for a stock 1″ or 1-1/8″ door. Add a wind chain if the door has none.
- Plain spring hinges plus a closer: the spring hinges close the door, and the closer still does the hold-open, so the tube stays.
- Waterson self-closing hinges: one set does the closing, the speed control and, in C or D, the hold-open, on a door 1-3/8″ or thicker that is within the set’s size and weight rating. The K51M is ANSI/BHMA A156.17 Grade 1, the standard for self-closing hinges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I replace my screen door closer with self-closing hinges?
Yes, if the wooden screen door is at least 1-3/8″ thick and within the hinge set’s size and weight rating. The hinges close the door, so the tube closer comes off. Waterson’s smallest self-closing hinge, the K51M-400, is listed for 1-3/8″ doors.
Can self-closing hinges hold a screen door open?
Yes, with a hold-open set. In Waterson’s C and D sets, one hinge holds the door at 85° ± 5°; the A and B sets only close the door.
What thickness are stock wooden screen doors?
Screen Tight’s stock wooden screen doors are listed at 1″ or 1-1/8″ thick. Custom makers build thicker doors; Vintage Doors goes from 1-1/8″ up to 1-3/4″.
My screen door is only 1-1/8 inches thick. Can I still use self-closing hinges?
Not Waterson’s: no Waterson K51M size is listed for a door thinner than 1-3/8″. Keep the tube closer, or build the replacement door 1-3/8″ or thicker.
How many self-closing hinges does a screen door need?
Three for a 36″ × 80″ screen door that weighs under 234 lbs. The Waterson K51M-400 has no published 2-hinge rating, and a 3-hinge set is rated for doors up to 7′ × 4′ and 260 lbs. A door over 7′ and up to 8′ takes a 4-hinge set.
Will a hold-open hinge keep my screen door open in the wind?
Do not count on it. The specifications cited here give no holding force for the hold-open, so keep a wind chain or a stop on a windy porch.
Which hinge set stops a screen door from slamming?
A B or D set. The hydraulic hinge in those sets adds damping for a smoother, quieter close; D also holds the door open.
Are self-closing hinges OK on an exterior screen door?
Use stainless steel. Waterson K51M hinges are investment-cast stainless steel, in US32D satin stainless or US19 flat black, with SS316 for more corrosive environments such as coastal sites.
To size Waterson hinges for a screen door, start with its thickness, height, width and weight.
See Waterson hold-open door hinges- ANSI/BHMA A156.17, Self Closing Hinges & Pivots — Grade 1; door closers are covered separately by ANSI/BHMA A156.4
- Screen Tight Woodcraft and Timberline wood screen door listings, “1 In. Thick” (Do it Best, Anderson Lumber, Kellogg Supply), 2026
- Vintage Doors, Cascade screen door product page, door thickness options, 2026
- Wright Products help centre, “Why won’t my hold open washer work?”, 2026
- Ideal Security, Storm Door Chain
- Waterson product documentation — K51M sizes and door thickness, hinge sets, hold-open, load ratings, material and finishes